[faqir]

as-salamu `alaikum

I asked shaykh Abul Hasan to comment on the narration with different wordings attributed to Mujahid b. Jabar - one of which seemingly may (incorrectly) imply attribution of makan to Allah and was discussed briefly here.

I've attached a pdf reply he recently sent me (may Allah reward his efforts). The document also has various other useful nuggets of information in it. Comments are welcome.

was-salam

Attached File(s)

•  Reply to Harris Hammam_on Makan narration from Mujahid-2.pdf (214.48K)
  Number of downloads: 48

[faqir]

as-salamu `alaikum,

Hanbalis who negate Makan

Not sure who the author is nor have I checked the quotes myself.

[Zhulfiqar]

Assalâmu 'Alaykum wa RahmatulLâh,

Sîdi Faqîr may Allâh reward you for sharing this, it was absolutely very useful, especially the quote of khalq af'aal from Imâm Bukhari (رحمه الله) about the 2 hanbali parties which is very new to me. May Allâh reward Shaykh Abu'l Hasan (حفظه الله) for the article, it's been a long time reading his wonderful articles